Imagine there is a knock at your door tonight. It is dark outside, and when you look through the window, you see a figure standing there with a face that doesn't look quite human. Under ordinary circumstances, you would probably feel your pulse immediately start to race and leave the door firmly closed. But tonight, you have a bowl of candy in your hand, and you are about to welcome whatever is on the other side of your door with excitement. Not only that, but that stranger may have walked up to the door of a house to ask for treats through a yard filled with dark beings or what is seemingly dismembered body parts and skeletons.
I have to say, we humans are a truly fascinating species. We spend most of the year trying to keep frightening things away from ourselves and our children, and then, for one evening, we dress the children as frightening things and send them out into the dark to demand candy from strangers. We intentionally put the horror in the yard and in our homes ourselves. We pay someone to chase us through a haunted house or a corn maze. And when it's over, we tell each other how much fun we had.
Hello friends and fellow seekers of truth. I'm Zac, and welcome to Reasonably Spiritual, a monthly series here on Delightfully Dharmic, where we explore the stories, beliefs, and mysteries that shape how we understand being human.
Before we begin, a small invitation: I don't claim to be the possessor of the truth. I think seeking it asks us to live with a paradox - to keep looking while remaining willing to loosen our grip on what we believe we've found. So, bring an open mind, follow what stirs your curiosity, and what makes room for peace in your inner being along the way. Also, I invite you to consider that knowledge and words can lead us toward understanding, but some things become known only through living them. Perhaps seeking brings us to the door, and experience invites us through.
And tonight, that is a rather fitting place to begin, with the holiday season approaching, and with me now here in Europe, I want to follow that strange little impulse. Why do we invite the monsters closer? What are we hoping to discover when we make a game out of death, evil, and the unknown?
The story I will share with you today takes us through ancient seasonal gatherings, visiting spirits, Christian holy days, and the beginnings of the Halloween we now recognize. Along the way, I want us to keep one question with us: when we open that door, are we meeting something outside ourselves, or something we have been avoiding within?
For now, let's step away from the porch and into a much older story, where someone accepts a dare that perhaps they should have politely declined.
Imagine a cold autumn night in the Ireland of legend, some two thousand years ago, in the time of Queen Maeve. At Rath Cruachan * rah kroo-uh-khun, her royal stronghold in the west, a household gathers around the fire. Beyond the fortress walls, the countryside has been swallowed by the cold darkness. Imagine mist gathering against the earthworks of the fortress, damp wool steaming near the hearths, and the smell of woodsmoke mingling with the evening meal being prepared. Inside, the household of King Ailill and Queen Medb has gathered around the fire, where a cauldron hangs over the heat and conversation fills the spaces between the crackling logs.
Outside, hanging like shadowed apparitions in the mist, two bodies hang from the gallows.
They were captives, executed the previous day, and everyone inside knows they are out there, in the cold night. It is the sort of knowledge that becomes easier to ignore when you pull closer to the fire and somebody begins another story. But this is a night when stories have a way of reaching into the room, and eventually the king proposes a challenge: a reward for whoever will walk out into the darkness and fasten a band of woven twigs around the ankle of one of the dead men.
You can imagine the confidence that follows a proposal like that, offered among friends with a warm fire at your back. Surely someone will do it. Surely there is nothing to fear from a man who has already been hanged. Yet one after another, those who venture outside return without completing the task.
Then Nera rises.
The king promises him a sword with a golden hilt, and Nera arms himself and leaves the warmth behind. Picture the household sounds fading as he approaches the gallows, until the shapes ahead resolve into something unmistakably human. He reaches toward an ankle and tries to secure the band, but it springs loose. He tries again, then a third time, fumbling with something that ought to be simple.
And from above him, a voice explains that he is fastening it incorrectly.
I have to tell you, receiving practical advice from the corpse would have brought my participation in this particular competition to an immediate end. Nera, however, follows the instructions. The band holds, and the dead man, apparently satisfied, asks him for another favor.
He was thirsty when they hanged him. Would Nera carry him somewhere he can get a drink?
What began as a dare has become an obligation to something that should no longer be able to ask for anything. Nera takes the corpse onto his back and carries it through the night, searching from house to house until they find water. But the encounter turns deadly: after drinking, the corpse spits the last mouthful over the people inside, and they die.
By the time Nera returns the body to the gallows, the prospect of a sword must feel very far away. He turns toward home, toward the household he left gathered around its meal.
And finds devastation.
The stronghold appears burned. His people have been slaughtered. Where there should be warmth and familiar voices, there is the terrible evidence of an attack he somehow never heard.
Ahead of him, a company of warriors is moving away through the darkness. Nera follows them toward the cave of Cruachan, where they begin passing into the earth. He draws closer, trying to understand what he has seen, until the last figure in the procession notices that someone has joined them.
Word travels forward through the company.
There is a living man following the dead.
And Nera, who stepped outside to win a sword, follows them beneath the ground.
We're going to leave him there for a little while, with the darkness closing around him and the fate of everyone he knows still unanswered. Because before we discover what is waiting inside that hill- and what he might possibly bring back -we need to understand why this was a night when a doorway could lead somewhere other than home.
The night on which it happens has a name: Samhain, often pronounced something like "SOW-in," with that first syllable rhyming with "cow," though pronunciations vary.
In the Irish tradition, Samhain marks the beginning of winter, associated with November first and the preceding evening. Its supernatural associations appear in medieval Irish stories, including Nera's. Those stories give us a window into an older imagination, although they are literature preserved in a later, Christian setting, rather than recordings of an ancient ceremony.
To understand why this turning of the year mattered, imagine depending on what you have gathered, stored, and raised to carry you through winter. You cannot simply order more food if the supply runs low. Darkness lasts longer, growth slows, and your relationship with your neighbors may help determine how well you endure the months ahead. The changing season is something your body and household have to answer to.
It makes sense that people would gather around a moment like that, preparing for what comes next and wondering about what cannot be controlled. The landscape itself seems to be crossing a boundary. In the stories, people and spirits cross boundaries too.
And somewhere in our modern picture of this older world, a white-robed figure usually appears beneath a tree. Before we follow him, we should ask how much of that picture belongs to history and how much we have supplied ourselves. We should talk about the Druids.
The Druids were religious and learned authorities in ancient Celtic societies, especially known to us through accounts of Gaul, broadly the region of present-day France and neighboring lands, and Britain. Julius Caesar describes them as teachers and judges as well as religious specialists. He associates their instruction with the heavens, the natural world, and the survival of the soul, and says students could spend years memorizing their teachings.
He also makes disturbing claims about human sacrifice, including the famous account of enormous wicker figures containing people who were burned alive. We cannot select his flattering descriptions and ignore everything uncomfortable. We also have to remember that Caesar was conquering the people he described. His testimony comes with the interests and assumptions of a powerful outsider.
That complicates the familiar idea that the Church invented every dark story about the Druids. Some of the most frightening accounts came from pagan Romans before Christianity became the empire's dominant religion. Christian hostility toward pagan practices matters later, but it is one part of a much longer history of people describing, opposing, and imagining one another.
For me, taking the Druids seriously means allowing them to have been human. They belonged to societies with learning, spiritual commitments, political power, and conflict. We can investigate claims of violence without reducing an entire tradition to a horror scene, and remain open to their wisdom without assuming they possessed every secret we wish we still knew. We do not have a surviving ancient Druid handbook that tells us exactly what happened at Samhain.
What we do have are stories about a world that could become unexpectedly porous. You might walk the same road you had walked all your life and encounter something that changed your understanding of where you were. Today, people often describe that possibility by saying the veil between worlds becomes thin. It is a beautiful expression, as long as we do not mistake our familiar wording for a verified quotation from an ancient Druid.
And Ireland was never alone in imagining a dangerous evening at the edge of winter. In Wales, Calan Gaeaf means the beginning of winter, and the night before it gathered its own frightening traditions, including tales of a tailless black sow abroad in the dark. Across the water, in Galicia in northwestern Spain, folklore tells of the Santa Compaña, a procession of restless souls traveling the roads. Imagine seeing a group approaching and gradually realizing that you do not want them to notice you.
These traditions have their own histories. The Christian imagery in the Galician procession belongs to the story we actually have; declaring it an unchanged ancient Celtic ceremony would take more evidence. Still, the resemblance invites a question. Why do so many communities imagine the dead crossing back into familiar places?
If we travel farther back, the question takes us into a Roman household in May. In Ovid's account of the Lemuria, a festival concerned with restless spirits, someone rises at midnight, throws black beans behind him, and asks the ancestral spirits to leave. There is food, darkness, and an invisible presence, but this household is trying to end the visit.
In the ancient Iranian religion of Zoroastrianism, we find a different reception. A festival called Frawardigan honors the departed around the religious year's end. An ancient hymn describes the fravashis of the righteous visiting their former homes and receiving offerings. Fravashis are spiritual protectors associated with persons, a category more complex than simply "ghosts." For our purposes, notice the welcome: the living prepare to receive those connected with them beyond death.
One household wants its visitors gone; another makes room for them. Neither account establishes a direct path into Halloween, but together they show how old and varied this relationship is. Traditions can travel through contact, develop alongside one another, or emerge independently from experiences human beings share. A resemblance gives us something to investigate, rather than a complete family tree.
It also asks us to be more careful with the word "supernatural." The dead, the dangerous, and the evil do not all belong in the same category. A noise at the door means one thing when you fear something outside. It means something entirely different when you wish the person standing there could be someone you have lost.
Later Irish Halloween customs hold those feelings together. People feared harmful spirits, but they also anticipated the return of deceased family members. Feasting and games could sit beside remembrance and caution. You could imagine a world full of unseen presences without assuming every one of them wanted to harm you.
Among Yoruba communities in West Africa, Egungun traditions give ancestral presence a visible place in communal life through elaborate ceremonial masquerade. Here, "masquerade" refers to a sacred performance with religious responsibilities, rather than a costume party. The ancestors remain connected with the living community and its obligations.
The Hopi, an Indigenous people whose homeland is in what is now the southwestern United States, offer another way of understanding a spiritually inhabited world. You may encounter the word katsina, or its plural, katsinam. These are sacred spirit beings within Hopi religious life. Hopi author Alph Secakuku describes their ceremonial presence as physical embodiments of spirits, with prayers concerning rain, growth, peace, and the well-being of the world. They should not be reduced to dead relatives in costumes, or described as a Hopi version of Halloween.
I bring these traditions into our story because they widen the question. An encounter with the unseen can concern the responsibilities of being alive together. It can ask what we owe the world, our community, and those who came before us. That is a different feeling from merely wondering what might jump out of the dark.
Now return to our autumn doorway in Europe, where another history is unfolding. Halloween takes its name from All Hallows' Evening, the evening before All Saints' Day. "Hallows" means holy ones, or saints. In the Western Christian calendar, November first honors the saints, while November second, All Souls' Day, became particularly associated with prayer for the departed.
Those observances developed over centuries, and commemorations of saints existed on other dates before November first became widely established. The familiar story of one pope taking Samhain, renaming it, and handing it back to everyone is much tidier than the evidence allows. What eventually emerges is a season shaped by Christian worship, regional customs, and older associations, sometimes blending and sometimes creating tension.
You can probably recognize how that happens without traveling very far. People adopt beliefs while continuing to tell their grandmother's stories. They can attend a religious service and still hesitate before walking past a particular place after dark. Our lived spiritual worlds can be considerably more crowded than our official statements of belief.
Even the person asking for something at the door has several ancestors. In parts of Britain, "souling" meant seeking food in connection with prayers for the dead. In Scottish and Irish "guising," people visited in disguise and might offer a song, a joke, or another performance. These customs belong in discussions of trick-or-treating's ancestry, although we cannot turn them into one perfectly continuous ritual stretching back into antiquity.
And beside that doorway, eventually, a face begins to glow. Before the familiar orange pumpkin, there were frightening lanterns carved from turnips. The National Museum of Ireland preserves a cast associated with a Donegal tradition remembered from around 1900. If you have seen one of those old turnip faces, you will understand why it deserves a place in this story. A pumpkin can look cheerful despite its teeth. A turnip can look as though it knows something about your family that nobody has told you.
Lantern folklore also gives us Jack, a figure refused entry to both Heaven and Hell and left wandering with a light. The details change between tellings, but that image remains: someone outside every home, carrying a little brightness through the darkness. We will come back to that feeling of being shut out, because it belongs to more than ghost stories.
Irish and Scottish immigration helped carry Halloween traditions into North America during the nineteenth century. Pumpkins became central to the celebration, and older visiting customs changed alongside parties, neighborhood mischief, and organized festivities. Efforts to channel destructive pranks into community celebrations helped shape the holiday, while trick-or-treating spread widely during the twentieth century, particularly around its middle decades.
Eventually, we arrive at the porch where we began, complete with costumes, candy, and a neighborhood agreeing to behave differently for one evening. Businesses have found plenty of ways to sell us things along the way, but a company can only sell a plastic skeleton if someone wants to put it in the yard. The question of why we want it is still waiting for us.
Picture a child asking a trusted adult to be a monster. The adult growls, the child runs, and soon there is some combination of screaming, hiding, and laughter, followed by a request to do it again. The game depends on a relationship. The person chasing the child is also someone who will stop, notice distress, and help the child feel safe.
Within that relationship, a powerful feeling becomes something the child can approach. Clinical psychologist Jordan Peterson discusses related ideas in his lectures on play and mythology: play allows people to negotiate boundaries around force and aggression, while stories explore how we might face a threat without becoming destructive ourselves. Applied to Halloween, that offers a useful possibility. Giving fear a form may help us learn how to meet it.
There is research on this experience, too. In a field study at a haunted attraction, researchers including Marc Malmdorf Andersen and Mathias Clasen examined visitors' fear, enjoyment, and physiological responses. Enjoyment tended to peak around a level of fear that was exciting without becoming overwhelming. More terror did not automatically produce more fun.
Anyone whose friend has described a haunted house as "not that scary" and then cheerfully disappeared ahead of them can probably appreciate that finding. What one person finds thrilling may be too much for someone else. The study helps us understand the relationship between fear and pleasure; it does not establish that frightening people automatically makes them resilient, or that every hesitant child needs a push.
For me, the interesting possibility is that a chosen, bounded experience allows us to notice fear, respond to it, and discover that it changes. Then we step outside with other people, laugh about who screamed, and begin turning the experience into a story. Something frightened me, and now I can tell you what it was like.
That is one way imagination gives us room to explore what ordinary life may make difficult to approach. But there is another reason to spend time with monsters, and it is considerably less comfortable. Sometimes the frightening thing in a story gives a face to something we would rather not recognize in ourselves.
Carl Jung, the Swiss psychiatrist, called the parts of ourselves we fail or refuse to acknowledge the "shadow." The shadow includes more than harmful impulses; we can also suppress tenderness, confidence, or gifts we learned were unwelcome. For tonight, though, I want to stay with the anger, envy, hunger for power, and capacity for cruelty that can conflict with the person we believe ourselves to be.
Jung also proposed a "collective unconscious," an inherited dimension of the mind expressed through recurring patterns he called archetypes. Think of a pattern such as entering an unknown realm, meeting a threatening figure, and returning changed. Different cultures give those patterns particular characters and meanings. That is a way to interpret recurring stories, rather than proof that every tradition comes from one source or that its spirits are only psychological symbols.
The part that concerns me most is what happens when I become convinced that the danger exists entirely in other people. Once I decide I am the good person in the story, I may stop examining the things I permit myself to do. My anger becomes righteous, my contempt becomes honesty, and controlling someone becomes something I am doing for their own good.
It can happen incrementally. Imagine someone who begins by wanting to protect a community. A difficult question starts to feel disloyal. A person who asks it becomes a problem. Embarrassing that person seems justified because the cause matters, and eventually even their distress becomes evidence that they deserved the treatment. Every step can arrive with an explanation that preserves the speaker's sense of goodness.
I want to be able to recognize that movement in myself before it reaches its final form. A capacity I acknowledge can become a responsibility I take seriously. A capacity I insist I could never possess can work beneath the protection of that certainty. Facing it means learning to restrain and redirect it, and making amends when we fail. It does not mean surrendering to it.
Halloween's monsters are useful here because they seem so easy to identify. They have the teeth, the strange face, the unmistakable costume. Real cruelty often arrives looking much more respectable, which brings us to Mary Shelley's Frankenstein.
Victor Frankenstein wants to cross the boundary between life and death, and his imagined triumph includes the gratitude and glory he expects to receive. When he succeeds in creating life, he recoils from the being he has made and abandons it. The creature longs for companionship, encounters rejection, and eventually commits terrible violence. In one especially painful episode, he saves a girl from drowning and is shot by a man who sees him near her. His appearance determines the response before his action can be understood.
The famous torch-bearing mob belongs especially to the film tradition, rather than being the scene to use as a summary of Shelley's novel. Her story already gives us plenty to confront: ambition without adequate care, rejection, revenge, and suffering passed onward. The creature's suffering helps explain his anger; it does not excuse the murders he chooses to commit.
Remember Jack, wandering outside every home? Shelley's creature gives that loneliness a painfully human voice. And the moral problem becomes recognizable once we leave the laboratory behind. We can want to accomplish something admirable and become careless about the lives caught inside our ambition. We can want safety and begin treating a person's difference as sufficient evidence of danger. We can have been wounded and slowly give ourselves permission to wound someone else.
The language we use to justify those choices matters. If every harmful thing I do is a necessary exception, while every harmful thing someone else does reveals their true nature, I have built myself a very comfortable place from which to become cruel. The story asks me to look again before deciding who has earned the name "monster."
And perhaps that gives us a way to explore the monster as an archetype, a recurring imaginative pattern. I wouldn't offer one definition that explains every culture's demons or every frightening creature. But one powerful interpretation is a relationship that has become distorted: appetite without concern for another life, power without responsibility, or injury that has turned into a desire to make everyone suffer.
Religious language may picture that as separation from divine goodness or light. A story may show someone shut out from community. In ordinary life, we might recognize a loss of connection with the people and living systems that make our own existence possible. That is the thread I hear when we say something about our way of living has become "unnatural."
I want to be careful with that word, though. Nature contains disease and predation, and human invention gives us things such as medicine. Being manufactured does not automatically make something harmful, any more than being natural makes it good. What concerns me is whether the ways we organize life honor the conditions under which life can flourish.
A screen can bring us together across continents. It can also become the place we repeatedly go instead of attending to the person beside us. Solitude can restore us, while an entire life without belonging may leave a profound ache. Someone experiencing isolation deserves companionship and care; loneliness is no evidence of moral failure or a destiny to become violent.
We can ask a similar question about food, while remembering that a chemical name or an artificial sweetener does not, by itself, tell us whether something is harmful. What concerns me is the relationship we build around eating: whether convenience, constant sweetness, and selling more begin to matter more than nourishment, shared meals, and attention to the body. The question is what serves a life, and whether we have allowed that question to disappear beneath what sells.
And when we look at the natural world, we can ask what kind of relationship we are building there. We depend on soil, water, other species, and processes we did not invent. We can work in reciprocity, taking what we need while caring for the conditions that replenish it, or pursue extraction as though the consequences belong to someone else. Calling the second approach progress does not release us from those consequences.
These are everyday choices, a long way from a laboratory or a haunted house, but stories can help us notice their direction. What are we feeding? What are we abandoning? Who bears the cost of the thing we have decided is good? Those questions bring the monster close enough that we might recognize a harmful pattern while there is still time to change it.
Yet something is missing if we spend the whole evening speaking only about fear and wrongdoing. The skeleton on the porch also represents a fact that has nothing to do with anyone being evil. We die, and so do the people we love. Halloween places mortality beside monsters, but they ask different things of us.
You can explain death in a sentence and spend a lifetime learning what it means. There will be a last ordinary conversation whose importance you may not recognize while it is happening. Someone's chair will become empty, and the room will feel different even when everything else is in its place.
Across centuries, people have made that knowledge visible. The phrase memento mori means "remember that you must die." Medieval images of the Dance of Death brought people from different stations of life into the same procession. Halloween sometimes gives us a lighter entrance into that territory, letting us laugh at a skeleton while knowing what it represents. Humor gives us room to breathe around an enormous fact.
And the returning dead can express longing as much as fear. You may no longer be frightened by the idea of a presence in the house if it could be the person whose voice you miss. Their expressions still enter your speech, their values shape a decision, and the relationship continues to affect your life after their physical absence has become undeniable.
That is where I want to approach the mystical part of this story, and where it becomes a little more personal for me. Of the spiritual traditions I have explored, Advaita Vedanta is the one I have come to resonate with most. It is a Hindu philosophical tradition whose name points toward "not two," or nonduality: the teaching that our apparent separateness does not describe the deepest reality of what we are.
That can sound abstract, so let's meet another person at a doorway. In the Katha Upanishad, one of Hinduism's ancient philosophical scriptures, a young seeker named Nachiketa comes before Yama, the lord of death. He wants to know what remains when a person dies. Yama offers wealth, pleasure, and a long life instead, but Nachiketa keeps returning to his question. Even the longest life eventually brings him back to the same threshold.
There is something deeply human about that refusal to be distracted. He has reached the person who might be able to answer, and he is not going to settle for a more comfortable way to postpone asking. The teaching turns toward Atman, the deepest Self, described as unborn and undying. Advaita understands that Self as identical with Brahman, ultimate reality, rather than fundamentally separate from it.
Here, "Self" means something deeper than my personality, memories, or the story I tell about Zac. The question becomes: is that story the whole of what I am, or might my deepest nature be something I habitually overlook beneath everything that changes? I am drawn to the invitation to examine that directly, rather than only collecting ideas about what happens after death.
This doesn't require me to pretend that grief is unreal or that harm stops mattering. If anything, contemplating that my life is not fundamentally separate from the life around me makes care more demanding. The person I am tempted to dismiss cannot so easily remain someone whose suffering has nothing to do with me. That is how the teaching speaks to me; it is not a claim that repeating "everything is one" makes someone compassionate.
Hindu religious life also contains concrete ways of honoring particular ancestors. During Pitru Paksha, a period dedicated to the departed, many families offer prayers, food, and acts of generosity. Such observances and Advaita's inquiry into the Self address different dimensions of religious life, and Hindu traditions do not all explain them alike. We can remember a person by name while still asking what a person ultimately is.
Advaita also offers a familiar teaching image that feels especially appropriate on an evening devoted to fright. In dim light, you see a snake in your path and recoil. When you look more carefully, you discover a rope. Something was there, and your fear occurred, but your interpretation of what you encountered was mistaken.
I find that image useful because it allows respect for an experience alongside curiosity about its explanation. If you feel an unexpected presence, have a vivid dream of someone who died, or experience an unusual sense of connection, you can ask what happened without immediately deciding what it proves. Memory, expectation, and perception deserve consideration. So does the meaning the experience has in your life.
The rope analogy illustrates ignorance and recognition within Advaita; applying it to a strange evening is my way of borrowing its question. What did I encounter, and what did I add? Staying open to that question can protect us from forcing everything into the first explanation that makes us comfortable.
I also don't think a psychological account automatically exhausts what an experience might mean. Perhaps some experiences involve aspects of reality our current understanding does not adequately grasp. That possibility deserves careful curiosity, while mystery by itself cannot establish a supernatural explanation. I can leave a question open without filling the opening with certainty.
There are things we learn through participation that explanation alone cannot give us. Reading about grief does not fully convey how it changes an afternoon. Defining trust cannot reproduce what it means to place yourself in another person's care. Ritual may sometimes work in that space: sharing food, speaking a name, sitting quietly, or returning to a place brings something into awareness that discussion alone leaves distant.
That is why I want to make room for knowledge embedded in experience, while remembering that the interpretation of an experience remains something we can examine. A profound moment may teach us about our relationships or ourselves even when we cannot establish what caused it. We can attend to what it asks of us without claiming to have solved the universe.
And now we can return to Nera, who has been waiting rather patiently for us on the other side of his strange adventure. When we left him, he had followed a company of mysterious warriors into the cave beneath Cruachan. Behind him lay the apparent destruction of his home. Ahead of him, word was passing through the procession that a living man had entered their world.
Imagine following those figures deeper into the earth, knowing that someone ahead has noticed you, while every step takes you farther from anything familiar. You have already heard a corpse speak. You have seen the place you called home reduced to ruin. Whatever rules you thought governed the world have become rather difficult to rely on.
Yet what Nera finds beyond the darkness is a place with a king, a household, and people going about their affairs. There is even work to be done. The king questions him, sends him to a woman who will receive him, and requires him to bring firewood each day. Apparently, crossing into another realm does not necessarily get you out of your chores.
The woman welcomes him, and Nera begins a life there. But beneath these unfamiliar routines, one image remains with him: the destruction he witnessed outside. Eventually, he tells her what he saw—the stronghold burned, the household slaughtered, everyone he had left around the fire apparently gone.
And she tells him something that changes the meaning of the entire night.
What he saw has not happened.
The devastation was an appearance shown to him by a supernatural host. It is a warning of what will happen when Samhain returns, unless his people are warned and act against the threat.
Imagine trying to take that in. The people you thought were dead may still be alive. The home you thought you had lost may still be standing. Somewhere beyond this place, there may still be time to do something.
Nera asks how he can warn them, and the woman tells him to go back. His people are still gathered around the same cauldron. The meal has not yet been taken from the fire.
To him, three days and three nights have passed.
Back home, supper is still cooking.
I love the way the story gives us that detail. It doesn't stop to explain how time works between worlds. It gives us a household waiting for its meal, while a man who stepped outside has lived through something that has rearranged his understanding of reality.
But Nera recognizes another problem. If he returns to that room, to people who have scarcely had time to notice his absence, why should they believe him? He can describe the journey, the warning, the woman who spoke to him, but to everyone listening, he will still be the man who just went outside to tie a band around a dead man's ankle.
The woman's answer is wonderfully simple: bring back the fruits of summer.
So Nera gathers wild garlic, primroses, and buttercups—living plants from another season—and carries them back toward the world he knows.
Picture him approaching the stronghold again. This time, there is no devastation. The household is there, gathered around the same cauldron, just as she promised. We can imagine how ordinary their conversation must sound to him, how strange it might feel to hear someone discussing a meal when he has seen their death and returned with a chance to prevent it.
And there he stands with summer in his hands.
Outside, winter is beginning. Inside, he has something that should not belong to this night.
He tells them what happened, gives his warning, and receives the sword he was promised. But his adventure does not end with a prize and a place beside the fire. He now has ties to the world beneath the hill. The woman becomes his wife, and they have a son. He crosses between worlds again, carrying responsibilities in both.
When the threatened season approaches, the king and Queen Maeve's people prepare to attack the Otherworld stronghold before its warriors can destroy their own. The tale moves into conflict, the removal of cattle, and the taking of treasures. It does not resolve into an uncomplicated lesson about everyone learning to understand each other.
And its final detail leaves something unsettled.
After the attack, Nera is left with his family in the Otherworld. The storyteller tells us that he has not come out again, and will not until the Day of Judgment.
The man who stepped outside for a dare has become someone who belongs beyond the doorway.
There is something haunting about that ending. He returned with a warning. He stood among his people with evidence of another season. Yet the story ultimately leaves him somewhere we cannot follow, living a life that no longer fits entirely inside the world where it began.
And still, of everything he encounters, it is those flowers I keep returning to.
Within the tale, they are evidence of his journey. For us, they offer a question to carry home: what comes back with us from an encounter with mystery?
Perhaps we return from a frightening story more able to recognize our own capacity for harm. Perhaps remembering the dead makes us more attentive to the people still here. Perhaps a spiritual experience loosens our certainty that we are isolated beings, each struggling alone against the rest of existence. Those changes do not prove a supernatural claim, but they give us something real to examine in the way we live.
That matters to me because an experience can feel extraordinary while leaving our behavior untouched. I want to know whether the insight survives the next difficult conversation, whether it changes how I use power, and whether I can hear someone telling me that I have hurt them without immediately retreating into the story of how good my intentions were.
It is possible to speak beautifully about compassion and become unkind the moment we feel challenged. It is possible to describe the unity of all things while treating the person in front of us as an obstacle. Whatever we believe we have discovered beyond ordinary understanding, eventually we return to someone who needs us to listen, a responsibility we would rather avoid, or a choice nobody else will see.
That is where I want to look for the flowers.
We began with a knock at the door, wondering what might be outside, and have found ourselves asking what kind of people we become when we decide whom to welcome, whom to fear, and whom we are willing to understand.
Halloween doesn't require everyone to do all that work. Sometimes the evening can simply be candy, laughter, and an unnecessarily elaborate costume. But if you want to look a little deeper, the stories are waiting. They give us a way to approach what frightens us together, with enough distance to remain curious and enough closeness to feel why it matters.
So enjoy the costumes, tell a good story, and remember someone whose absence still matters. If something frightens you, take a moment to look carefully. If someone seems strange to you, leave room to discover who they are. And if you recognize a little of the monster in yourself, perhaps that recognition can become the beginning of greater responsibility and care.
As for what may actually wait beyond the doorway, I'm willing to keep wondering. I just hope that whatever we encounter, we bring something worthwhile back into the lives we share. Preferably flowers, rather than a very persuasive reason to be cruel.
I'm Zac, and this has been Reasonably Spiritual. Thank you for spending a little time in the dark with me.
Sources and further reading
Historical sources, literary texts, research, and practitioner accounts supporting the episode. Comparisons between traditions do not establish direct influence. Reflections on ethics, modern life, and mystical experience are the host's interpretations. Sources are kept outside the spoken script.
- 1.Kuno Meyer, editor and translator (1889). The Adventures of Nera. Medieval Irish tale, published in Revue Celtique 10, pp. 212–228. Source for the opening dare, the speaking corpse, and the Otherworld journey. A literary source, not an eyewitness account of ancient ritual.
- 2.University College Cork, Department of Early and Medieval Irish (2022). Here Comes Summer!(?). Samhain as the beginning of winter; Nera's return with wild garlic, primroses, and buttercups; the story's altered time.
- 3.Julius Caesar. The Gallic War, Book VI, chapters 13–16. Primary Roman account of Druids as teachers, judges, and religious authorities, including Caesar's claims about sacrifice. Read in the context of his role as a conqueror.
- 4.National Museum of Ireland. Traditions and customs of Halloween / Samhain. Irish seasonal customs, feasting, games, masks, harmful spirits, and expectations that deceased family members might return.
- 5.Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911). All Saints, Festival of. Historical overview of All Saints observance and its changing calendar dates. Used for the broad chronology, not as proof of a deliberate replacement of Samhain.
- 6.Library of Congress (2021). The Origins of Halloween Traditions. Overview of souling, guising, and other proposed antecedents of modern trick-or-treating. The script does not adopt every ancient-origin claim in this overview.
- 7.National Museum of Ireland. Ghost turnip. Museum object and collection history documenting turnip lanterns, the Donegal tradition, and the wandering Jack legend.
- 8.TIME (2017), including historian Nicholas Rogers. The History of Trick-or-Treating on Halloween. Immigration, neighborhood mischief, organized celebrations, and the development of Halloween in North America.
- 9.Stephen Winick, Library of Congress (2020). Masking and Mumming for the Holidays, Thanksgiving Style! Folklorist's discussion of multiple seasonal visiting traditions and the twentieth-century spread of trick-or-treating.
- 10.Jordan B. Peterson (2015). Maps of Meaning 05b: Narrative, Neuropsychology & Mythology III / Part 1. Lecture discussing play, aggression, boundaries, and narrative. The application to Halloween is the episode's interpretation, rather than a finding that establishes Halloween's origins.
- 11.Marc Malmdorf Andersen, Uffe Schjoedt, Henry Price, Fernando E. Rosas, Coltan Scrivner, and Mathias Clasen (2020). Playing With Fear: A Field Study in Recreational Horror. Psychological Science 31(12), pp. 1497–1510. Field study of 110 haunted-attraction visitors examining fear, enjoyment, and physiological responses. It does not establish universal resilience benefits or Halloween's ancient purpose.
- 12.National Museum of Ireland. Memento Mori. Mortality in material culture and art, including the Dance of Death tradition.
- 13.Ovid. Fasti, Book V, lines 419–444. Primary literary description of the May Lemuria ritual. Included as an ancient parallel, not an established ancestor of Halloween.
- 14.William W. Malandra, Encyclopaedia Iranica. Frawardigan. Zoroastrian observance and the Avestan account of returning fravashis. Calendars and local practices vary.
- 15.National Trust. Calan Gaeaf in Wales. Welsh winter traditions and supernatural folklore; compare Museum Wales's Tailless Black Sow resource.
- 16.Turismo de Galicia. Túnica, cánticos y rezos. Terror en torno a la Santa Compaña. Regional account of the spectral procession. Supports the living folklore, not an unchanged ancient Celtic origin.
- 17.Genealogy (2019), volume 3, article 7. Ará Òrun Kìn-ìn Kin-in: Òyó-Yòrùbá Egúngún Masquerade in Communion and Maintenance of Ontological Balance. Research on ancestral communion and communal responsibilities in Egungun traditions.
- 18.Heard Museum, drawing on Hopi author Alph H. Secakuku. Hopi gallery teaching resource. Public account of katsinam as spiritual embodiments, with emphasis on peace, growth, and collective well-being. This comparison does not equate katsinam with ghosts or Halloween costumes.
- 19.International Association for Analytical Psychology. The collective unconscious. Jung's distinction between inherited archetypal patterns and personally acquired experience. Their application to this episode is interpretive.
- 20.Katha Upanishad; translation hosted by Shankaracharya.org. Nachiketa and Yama. See I.1.20–29 for the question and offered alternatives, and I.2.18 for the deathless Self. Hindu scripture presented as religious teaching.
- 21.Vedanta Society of Southern California. What is Vedanta? Practitioner explanation of Atman and Brahman. The episode identifies nonduality specifically with Advaita rather than all Hindu philosophy.
- 22.Siddha Yoga. Pitru Paksha: The Fortnight Dedicated to the Ancestors. Practitioner account of ancestor remembrance and offerings.
- 23.The Advaita Vedanta Home Page. Frequently Asked Questions. Atman and Brahman, liberating knowledge, and the rope–snake analogy.
- 24.Mary Shelley (1818). Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus. Primary novel. Victor's ambitions and abandonment, the creature's rejection and violence, and the rescue followed by a shooting underpin the literary discussion. The episode's moral interpretation is identified as interpretation.
- 25.Natalia Serebrennikova, International Association for Analytical Psychology. The Shadow. Explains disowned qualities, including positive qualities, and projection. Everyday examples of incremental cruelty are the episode's illustrations.
- 26.British Film Institute. Frankenstein (1931). Film identification for James Whale's adaptation, distinguished from Shelley's novel.